new tires rubbing aftermarket fender

Hi all,

I recently had my taco painted and a fender replaced, then put new wheels and tires on.

I've got a 97 4WD and I put 265/75/16's on (the new Toyo Open Country AT II's)

but now the drivers side front tire is rubbing the new fender. (the metal)

it sounds horrible any time I turn even slightly left so much that I don't want to drive the truck until its fixed but I am not quite sure how much is too much to trim or if I should be cutting into the metal on this thing.

any tips or advice for what to do here?

I'll try to upload a pic or two in just a minute.

Thanks in advance for the help
Zach