2008 trd sport or 2005 trd OR

These are the 2 I am looking at. Both seem a little overpriced...

2005 60k miles $20k
2008 100k miles $17,500
or stock 2008 with no lsd just open diffs 93k miles $16k

which is better for snow and some mud and some light trails?
and maybe the better overall truck?
thanks!

 

Technically, the OR is better for traction with the locking rear end. But I'd definitely go for the '08 Sport. It will have 3 years less rust buildup, the price is less, it looks better (skewp!) and for most purposes the locking rear end is not needed. I've gone through several feet of snow with 'regular' 4WD with no issues at all.

Either way, check out the frame closely for rust issues.

 

if you plan to use it off-road, and it is not 4x4 then OF. Package.
You will need the locker.

 

Providing these are all 4x4, you will get a whole lot of biased opinions on this question. If you plan on upgrading to a locker and/or gears, go with the Sport or the plain jane. If your not upgrading or modding, but go offroad alot, get the 2005 OR. Lots of options with any of these you pick. Just go with your gut and get the one you want.