Headlights that don't match HELP!

A few months ago the front passenger side of my regular cab 2007 truck was hit. As part of the repair the headlight assembly was replaced. I noticed th other day on the new light the color of the turn signal lense does not match the driver side. On inspection I found the replacement was not an OEM but an after market part from China. I have returned the truck to the body shop and they have agreed to replace it with an OEM assembly but today when i went to pick it up the new one from Toyota is clear and not yellow. It is an OEM Toyota part but it does not match the old one. I told the shop manager they must make different colors based on trim level. He claims no. I know we did this at the BMW plant I worked at. Can anyone help me out with this?

 

From what I've heard, you can open them up and simply take out that orange reflector to match. The bulbs are already orange I believe.

You'll find disassembly info in any BHLM thread.

 

If they cant find a passenger to match, tell them to replace the drivers side. Your truck should be repaired to the way it was prior. I atleast would not settle for anything less.