I've used both airaid and kn oiled filters on jeeps, trucks and atvs. I never had an issue with any of those. It is true, from my experience, that if you over oil a filter that oil will get sucked pased the filter.
I have decided this time to go with the afe stage two, oiled filter, in the box. This decision is made simply because I don't want as much sound in the cabin of my truck.
I think your seat of the pants dyno will tell you that whichever you choose was worth it. IMO CAI are worth the investment. You will also probably see a small MPG increase if you don't get addicted to the sound rush and can refrain from "just for the heck of it" fast accelerations.