If you're really serious about it.... then go take a few cooking classes, maybe even bring her with ya (she'll see it as a bonding experience), then apply what you've learned. You'll make a better dinner, have learned how to do it properly (rather than halfassing your way through it), and the outcome will be that much better.
If you go the steak route, make sure you get a good cut, from a quality butcher shop... never been to Mississippi but if you've got a Whole Foods, they have great meats there (anti-biotic free, sustainable growth practices and all that). Bone-in Rib Eye is a great cut IMO, but if you can find it, a cut of Chateaubriand cooked just right is so much better (hope you have some money over after Black Friday/Cyber Monday though... otherwise your Taco Mod Fund might need to be tapped into).
Don't just bake the potato either.... make some scalloped potatoes or dice em up and bake em with a light mist of olive oil and some fresh rosemary or oregano (or spice of your choice).
As for the asparagus, olive oil, fresh cracked pepper and sea salt, combine in a bag and mix it up for 15 mins, then grill it (get a grill tray if you need to).
I'd also suggest a loaf of bread for munching on beforehand, and a small side salad too.... you're not old enough (legally) to drink otherwise a good red wine would really top it off... So I guess you're left with non-alcoholic drinks - up to you on that.
Originally Posted by GP3
It's a trap.
And just so we're all on the same page with this girl, you should post some pics so we're giving you the right advice I can't believe no one's asked for them already