Headlight spread

My "new to me" 2010 has the driver's side headlight that has a funky star pattern coming off of it when it is on dim. So far, adjustment does not change the star pattern. I can see no damage or visible difference between the driver's side and the passenger side reflectors. Sound familiar to anyone?

I tried to add the picture below, but I think I failed. You can see the low beam picture, and a high beam picture by clicking on the camera to the left.

 

I have a 2010 and there is nothing like that on my truck. Did you buy it used? Other than that pictures would help.

 

I would guess that the piece protruding from the reflector bowl (the plastic bit that's in front of the bulb) is loose or was bent. Without pictures, it's tough to say, just a guess.