I picked up a pyrite mica 2011 PreRunner SR5 I4 a few weeks ago as my daily driver. I looked at F150s and Silverados, but decided for my needs, the Tacoma was the way to go, especially now that the I4 is offered in double cabs. I traded in an '06 Accord, and really couldn't be happier. It's comfortable, drives great, gets good mileage...pretty much everything I ask from my DD, plus it's a lot more convenient to have a bed, so we're not tearing up the interior of my wife's SUV.
It's not going to win any races, but that's not why I bought this vehicle. I have the Vette for that.