New member advice of tires

Hey everyone this is my first post. I've had my truck for around a year now (2013 4cly prerunner) and am counting down the days till I wear down the stock Dunlop tires that we're put on it when I bought it. I've been interested in BFG all terrians in the stock size (LT245/75/16) or nitto terra grapplers in P265/70/16.

The bfgs are the stock size but a LT tires which I don't need and the nittos are a passenger tire but a size bigger. What do you think would be a better option or is it a smarter decision to get something like the hancook dynapro ATM, toyo open country at2 or cooper at3 in the stock size and P rated? Any advice would help. Look forward to hearing your responses.

 

Stick with the light truck rated tires

 

This.