Have been looking for mats since I bought my truck a few months ago. I've been fishing every weekend and the driver and passanger side floor mats have been getting dirty.
I looked at the Weathertech ($117/front) and the Maxliner ($89/front). I went with the Maxliner due to cost and the lifetime warranty. Donwside is they are made in Thailand vs the USA.
I can't compare the Maxliner to the Weathertech as I never owned the Weathertech's.
The reviews for the Maxliner were all similiar to the Weathertech's so the decision was made.
I ordered them from AutoAnything.com and received them in two days. I received an extra $10 off plus free shipping so I think I got a good deal.
Install took 5 minutes- the retention post holes lined up perfectly. The fit is exact and it provides more coverage than the stock carpet mats. So far, I'm happy with the purchase.