Finally went a size up and I went with the Toyo AT II Open Countrys. I did quite a bit of research and comparison, pros and cons, etc... and here are the 2 main factors that sold me.
1. 41lbs each, my stock BFs were 38lbs each, so I am only gaining about 3lbs per tire, gas mileage and power factors.
2. Tread warranty, 65,000 miles
I like the look of the General Grabbers, but they are like 60lbs each, 10ply, etc... and for what I do that would just be a gas and power hog.