Toyo Open Country MT or BF Goodrich TA KO2

op look into dick cepek extreme country just got them on my taco, couldn't be happier 255 85 16s very fair priced as well

 

I second this! I have them in 265/75/16 and they are great! They have done very well in the mud and off road as well. They're also NOT that noisy on the streets and they look nice as well. I paid 700 shipped for a set of 4

 

You should check out the Toyo RT as well. I'm coming up on the same challenge & the attractive thing about the RT is that they are a less aggressive mud tire with good road manners & the have a 40k warranty versus no warranty on the MT. I ran BFGs on my 1st gen 4Runners & the ATs do not work well in the sticky mud.

 

X2 on the rt!
I'm going in today to order some to replace my ko2s.
I had them on my landcruiser and was impressed with them in just about every type of terain.
I do like the bfg as well and my only complaint with them is how bad they pick up gravel.
I do a lot of long dirt/gravel roads in the desert @ higher speed and it is destroying the side of my truck. The ko2 actually worked really well in the mud and snow when new but once they start to ware out a bit the offroad performance suffered tremendously.
This rings true with most at tires though.

 

I've run Toyo's on several of my trucks in the past and have always considered them to perform better than other brands I've tried.