Woman on Cell Phone in 1928 Movie??

http://www.urlesque.com/2010/10/27/time-traveler-cell-phone-1928-charlie-chaplin-film/?icid=main|main|dl10|sec1_lnk3|180697

Kinda Trippy.... Sure looks like shes talking on a cell phone. Not that i really beleive that.

 

hmmmmmmm doubt its a cell phone but who knows

 

they say she is. and some say shes not. but she is clearly talking when she turns towards the camera. unless she is singing to a handheld radio (if they even had those) i dont think its a phone.

 

say even if it was a time traveler like some have suggested. the woman could have a cell phone, but it wouldnt work unless she brought a cell phone tower and launched a satelite into space.

 

my g/f and i watched it a few times last night, found a website that had a picture of a 1920s hearing aid, that's most likely what it was. but it for sure looks like a cellphone

 

not sure where the satellite misconception comes from. satellites aren't used for phones except for GPS...but none the less, she would have to be from a future time when cell towers aren't needed...maybe then she'd need a satellite? idk..impossible i say.

 

hmmm didnt know that. about the hearing aid. but i see where your coming from

 

It looks like a bogus clip to begin with. I've seen enough old baseeball clips from that era to make me think somones scamming.

 

How could she have been talking on a cellular if there was no signals back than. That is silly. Same as somone trying to use a GPS 100 years ago.. You could be holding one, but surelly would not work.

 

On one part of the video when they slow it way down, and the end before they cut it. She clinches her hand in, at about the 56-57 second mark. So it would be impossible for Her to be holding something like a cell phone.
It looks like to me she is itching her ear.

And if she was a damn time traveler, her cell phone would be useless. Because there are no cell phone towers or satellites.

 

haha... this is funny. Hey.. if she could time travel im sure a phone that could send signals through time is possible. I agree with it probably being a hearing aide or shes just scratching though.

 

Maybe its an ice pack and she is cussing the person who hit her

 

I saw this at school today. haha

 

It's supposed to be from a movie so I'm sure one could find it elsewhere to view the clip.

Most I've hard think it is in fact a hearing aid.

 

Thats pretty crazy.

 

I just saw this on the knews, kinda weird.

 

Yea, that would be my first stop as a time traveler. A Chaplin movie from 1928.

 

I want to belieeeeeve.....

 

.

Hand held "box type hearing aid" of the time ... some models even had musical reeds in them.

.