Am I asking too much for these?

Not one legit call yet. Too high?
https://norfolk.craigslist.org/wto/d/virginia-beach-nitto-terra-grappler-g2/7151164813.html

 

I'd clean them up a bit and see if you get any bites. Have you posted it on FB marketplace as well?

 

X2 on the clean up. It might not seem like it is worth it to you, but little things like that go a long way when you are trying to sell something.

 

Kind of rude. Would discourage me from purchasing.

 

I've found that used tires have very little value. Doesn't matter how low the miles, nobody really wants used tires.

I have two Toyo AT/2's right now, almost full tread, that I literally can't even give away. Probably end up recycling them.

 

Yes

300 is a realistic asking price. Most people don't want tires that are too big for their vehicle.

 

Same. Selling tires and wheels once was the first and last time I’ll do that again. Tires (new) were basically sold for nothing and the wheels went free, and it took 3 weeks.

 

Sold them. Guy came over with $1000 in 50s and no change, so I caved and sold them for $950.
I was also selling two sheets of new T1-11 plywood on CL, $20/ea. Later that day a guy came over with a $100 bill and $38 in other bills. I took grudgingly took $38. What the hell is wrong with CL buyers. Have some respect and bring over the correct amount. Everyone expects a discount.