Quick question - Moto Metals

I'm thinking of getting Moto Metal 955's, but not sure which size. I prefer 16", but the specs are 16x8, 0 offset and 4.5 backspacing - would this fit my 2008? It's this or the 17x9, -12 offset with 4.5 backspacing. Would the 17's stick out a bit more or would they be the same? Thanks for any help!

 

My 955's just arrived (17x9), and wrapping them in BFG TA KO 275/70/17
Some time next week. They will stick out about 2" further than stocks but look great and not rub after my 2" lift is done.

 

Those specs are very similar. The 9" wide wheel will stick out 1" more, because it is one inch wider but has the same backspacing.