Which Phone Case?

I can't decide between 2 different cases for my Samsung Captivate. Both are about $30. And I plan to paint the hard black plastic part orange on either one I get.

Otterbox Defender:



Seidio Active:

 

the otter box offers more protection

 

I have the otter box and it's saved my I phone many times over it's worth the cost.

 

Im bad at going through phones pretty quick. I finally got the otter box for my DROID x and have dropped it numerous times, as well as left it on my hood, drove down the road, remembered I left it on there and stopped. The phone went flying off the truck and hit the pavement. I jumped out it was fine.

 

^^^ I know that was a big run on sentence. Sorry. ^^^

 

Haha I see what you did there!

 

I've had an Otter Box on a iPhone and they are bullet proof. But I took it off cause it made my phone too bulky in my pocket.

 

I didn't read the phone choice first