Advise needed on lift and tires

If I set my 5100's at 2.5, will I be able to run Nitto Trail Grapplers 285/65r18 with XD Monster 18 with -12 offset 4.53 back spacing? I don't want to do a CMC. I'm Ok with a little plastic fender cutting and removing the mudflaps.

OR

Would I be better off running Toyo Open Country MT's in 275/65r18?

Also i will not be doing any off road driving just want the look.
Thanks for the HELP!

 

Anyone have a thought on this?

 

Go with the Toyo's. I have a set at 45K that look almost new. Better tire and you know it won't rub. my .02

 

Is there anyone that is running this type of setup?

 

I used to run 275/65/18 with my CO's set at 2.5" with no issues. I'm running 285/75/16's now.
The 285's will require some minor plastic trimming front/behind the front tires but should be fine with your wheel BS of 4.5".