Wheel advice

I'd appreciate any input on the situation I'm currently in. I took my 2015 months back for my first service and when I got it back I noticed not one, but all my wheels had been damaged. After giving them several chances to fix it I ended up getting some trd black trail team wheels out of the deal.

Down the road I wanted to get new wheels and looks like they came early. Here is what I need advice on. My current bfg rugged trails have 4200 miles on them, so should I swap those out on the new wheels or pony up for bfg all terrains and try to sell the old tires and wheels? I have a few options here, but just would like some input. Thank you

 

Sell the old tires, and wheels while they are still low on miles. You won't find many here that will talk you into keeping the Rugged Trails. I've heard good things about the Rugged Terrains. I was looking at these myself before I got my Toyo's. It's a hybrid all terrain tire that has relatively low rolling resistance, are fairly light, and supposedly have a quiet highway ride.

 

I'm leaning that way to just sell them. If I ran 265/75/16 tires instead of the 265/70/16 would it be a noticeable difference at all?