I have a 2nd gen 2011 TRD Sport and I'm looking for advice on the best all terain tires

You can get 265/75/16 Duratracs in a C rating.

 

Best all around tire on the market is Toyo open country ATII. I like my Cooper ATIII also but they are on there because I got a smoking deal on Tirecrawler. Stay away from BFG KOs,compound is way too soft(I think they are made of chalk).Save some money and order online it will save you about 400 Id say.

 

Everybody is right, get 4 of each!

 

I agree, if you only use you're lil less off road, way more on road. Lasts forever BFG's. I think if more off road driving the Goodyear dura-tec. Traction is great. But c rating, lower load rating, and the 6 pyl. Their way lighter. Air up and down. Just my experience.

 

Currently have Duratracs on my 13. They now have almost 40k miles on them and they're getting pretty loud. They still stick good offroad in both sand and mud. They're starting to lose wet road traction though either due to sipping being worn away or the rubber getting harder from age. I have a set of Cooper AT3 sitting in the garage I'll be putting on probably this week.