Mudflap Repair

I accidentally pulled one of my mud flaps off backing over a curb. A couple of the mounting holes cracked. Does anyone have any experience with repairing these?

Please don't just tell to take them off. I'm one those old farts that likes the look of the mudflaps (I like the look of the white lettering on the tires too). With them they look like a Tacoma. Without them they just look like any other truck to me.

I'm trying to avoid buying a replacement so any ideas are welcome.

 

Pictures would help ?

Just how bad fender washers on both sides unless the holes are completely destroyed .