3rd gen driver door window controls - way to stop rattles?

What have you done to stop the driver’s door window controls from making noise when the mid bass hits?

With my ‘17 OR I tried sound deadening tiles and closed cell foam gasket material but it still made noise. Looking to put new speakers in my ‘19 and want to treat the doors right at the same time.

 

I put noico and felt tape on the door panel.
Noico every place 2 parts of the panel connect and felt tape/tessa tape on all the clips. This removed all the rattle I had.

 

Do you have a picture of what you did?

 

I feel like the window itself rattles like crazy on my 17. The slightest little crack to get air in makes it annoying to drive.

 

My 18 has done that since new, idk what it is but its annoying.

I dont, but when you take off the door panel you will see seams where 2 parts of the panel are put together. Cover those with a 1 inch wide strip of noico, then put tesa tape on all the clips where they connect to the panel.