265/70R17 or 255/75R17 on TRD Sema Wheel for a Sport No Lift

I'm trying to finalize the wheel tire package for my 2018 TRD Sport 4x4. I settled on the Toyota TRD Sema wheel, it's 17"x7" with a +4 Offset and BF Goodrich All-Terrains. Still not sure what size. Looking at 255/75R17 and 265/70R17. Prefer not to lift the truck, and planning a "C" load tire as I don't do anything very challenging or carry heavy loads. Any thoughts are appreciated.

 

Go big or go home. Consider: 275/70-17 or 255/80-17’s

 

I have a 2012 TRD Offroad, stock suspension with Falken Wildpeak 265/70R17 and Toyota TRD wheels. There was some rubbing while cranking the wheel sharply on the small, forward of front tire "mud flap" piece (not sure what this part is called but its not the regular behind the tire mud flap). I removed this "mini" forward mud flap piece and now there are no issues/rubbing. I could have left this piece on and it would have been fine but I chose to remove it.

 

I have a 19 OR and am looking at the same wheels and will put 255-75-17’s on. Just prefer the tall and skinny