Passenger Windshield Pillar bolt cover plate

While recently installing new dash speakers (Subaru), I managed to somehow 'mangle' (stretch to the point it lost its rigidity) the inch-long connector tab on the plastic bolt cover plate / trim piece. Please excuse my inarticulateness in describing this.

Now that cover plate won't fasten securely. What are my options? Replace the cover plate (source)? Just glue the plate back into position?

Yet another reason for me to forego DIY projects.

Thanks.

 

A picture would be helpful in this situation. Are you referring to the plastic cover for the passenger A pillar? Is it part of the grab handle?

 

Yes, it's part of the grab handle. Attached are a couple of photos.

 

Tacoma assist grip plug Part Number: 7461704070C0
Here's a link to the part https://parts.toyota.com/p/Toyota_2017_Tacoma/PLUG---ASSIST-GRIP-BLACK/66827070/7461704070C0.html
You can order the part yourself from any online Toyota parts store or from the dealer, just give them the part number. Should only cost about $4-6 with shipping.
Hope this helps!

 

GumShoe: Thanks for your help! Very much appreciated. You were right about the cost, $4.50.