Replacement fender flare options

Last night I was pulling out of a parking lot and accidentally swiped the front right corner of my tacoma on a cobblestone half wall, breaking off a part of my front fender flare (just installed last week sadly) and scratching the front bumper paint.

It's a black, plastic TAC (I believe) fender flare, and I currently can't find them online as I purchased them from an individual on Facebook Marketplace. Does anyone have suggestions on how to fix or replace this? If I can't find a placement flare, would gorilla glue of some sort be a reasonable "repair" option? Or does anyone happen to have options/suggestions for finding a replacement flare?

 

Toyota sells them individually. They are like $200 per flare though