1995 tacoma caliper bolt

I recently rebuilt the front end (aside from axel and calipers) and I stupidly mixed my bolts up for my left wheel.
I was like 70% sure the longer bolts were for caliper mounting. But upon re-installing the caliper the lower bolt sounds as though it's rubbing the rotor when I spin the wheel, causing a very cringey screech.
Does anyone happen to know which of these is correct for mounting the caliper? And if it is the longer bolt what could other potential problems could be causing this? I would hate to put a short shouldered bolt where a longer shoulder should be, although it isn't scratching like the longer bolt.

 

I would also like to say that the repair manual diagram looks like the long shoulder bolts, although it has no listed dimensions or part numbers.

 

Can you take the bolt out of the right side caliper and see?

 

Yeah, it just got dark tonight and being the last day off work this week I don't know when I can get around to it.
Figured I'd ask if anyone happens to have this random piece of knowledge lol

 

You have a 5-lugger? The PartSouq catalog mentions "12-1.25PX31", so the bolt should be 31mm long. Photo of the current bolt if you were to buy it at the dealer parts counter: https://parts.longotoyota.com/oem-parts/toyota-disc-brake-caliper-bracket-mounting-bolt-9011912058



If you have a 6-lugger, the bolt is "12-1.25PX35", 35mm long: https://parts.longotoyota.com/oem-parts/toyota-disc-brake-caliper-bolt-9010512175

 

Thank you!
And yeah its a 5 lug