Ripped Rear Mud Flap Off-Need Advice

Backed into hard packed snow yesterday and ripped one of my rear mud flaps off when it pushed against the tire. Pulled the screws right out of the holes. My question is should I try to replace it (screw holes are messed up) or just take the other one off and call it a day. Any advice would be appreciated.

 

Pictures would be a great. Do you have any? Can you take some? Take a picture with everything off(screws, flap, plastic push bolt/fasteners).

 

You could try to replace it. The front guards are the ones that help more(when it comes to protecting the side of the truck). I took mine off for a while. I put them back on because of the 4x4 on the rears.