2nd Gen - 16" or 17" rims for normal use?

I have a 2009 TRD Offroad, and sacrificed the stock 16" rims as a set dedicated to winter tires. So, I need to buy some cheapo rims for the rest of the year. I see stock TRD Sport and TRD Offroad rims for sale, so I guess I have my choice between the two sizes. I typically used one size bigger on the 16" rim (265/75/16) and I would assume I can get an equivalent larger size in a 17" if needed.

Can anyone even tell the difference in ride or MPG's? I won't be doing any hardcore 4-wheeling.

 

I think the ride is softer with a bigger sidewall. So the 16s.

 

MPG is mostly affected by the overall weight of the wheel/tire combo so try to keep the weight down as much as you can.

As Bobby mentioned, bigger sidewalls will provide a cushier ride, but the shorter sidewall could potentially provide better handling depending on your tire choice.

 

16s would be cheaper for tires (maybe), and give more sidewall cushion.