Best rubber floor mats?

4 sets for both 4R and Tacomas. My weathertechs were smooth underneath and my catch for the driver side is broken. These seem to be custom fit and work well

 

x(whatever number were on) for weathertechs, had mine for 3 years now and theyve been great

 

If you're up for a little guinea pigging, I have a suspicion that the 2001 "custom" floor mats offered by Weathertech will fit a 1999. Why they don't carry over, idk, but if you don't find out, eventually I will haha

 

I'm looking for a new pair as well. I feel like the ones I have right now have created a dusty smell in my truck.

 

Bringing this one back- I'm looking at the Weathertech as well, but according to their site, the LASER MEASURED FLOOR LINER (not the trim to fit floor mat) only fits the '01 to '04s with the automatic transmission. Anyone with a third pedal try one and how does it fit? I'm positive the floor is the same shape regardless- maybe the clutch pedal gets stuck behind the laser measured ones?

 

I ended up going with the Husky Liners. They run much higher up on the footrest than the Weathertechs. Hope they stay in place and don't move around!