Experience with aftermarket fender panels?

Got into a bit of an accident the other day in my 07. I spun out on a snowy/icy backroad and ended up in a ditch. My front drivers side panel is crinkled and caved in pretty bad. It wont allow the headlight to sit properly so ill need to replace it. Its really hard to find a junkyard second gen in Silver Streak Mica that doesnt have a damaged front drivers fender panel.

I considered maybe going aftermarket and just dealing with a black/primed panel for a little while. I would rather spend $80 for an unpainted panel than $300 for a junkyard panel of a different color that ill have to paint anyways. Does anyone have any experience with fitment for aftermarket fenders? Or could recommend any good brands/sites to buy off of?

Amazon has this fender for $80 Canadian which is a bargain and a half. Just concerned it wont line up properly or will have super shitty fitment.

$79 Sherman Replacement Part Compatible with Toyota Tacoma Front Driver Side Fender Assembly (Partslink Number TO1240208)

https://www.amazon.ca/gp/product/B004GD8DYC/ref=ox_sc_act_title_1?smid=A3DWYIK6Y9EEQB&psc=1