Four-door 2.7cyl Prerunner A/T tires and Rims

What's up everyone,

I have a 2012 four-door 2.7cyl Prerunner and...

After doing some research, it seems that I will be going for Toyo Open Country A/T III. They seem to be one of the lightest but nicely looking A/T tires (36-37 lbs). Even though I like the more aggressive ones like the KO2 (50lbs), Wildpeak or the Grabber ATX, I don't want to sacrifice so much speed on the Highway; Since I do most of my driving on that type of road.

I am stuck on whether to get 245/75/16 (36lbs)
With TRD Off-Road Wheel - 3rd Gen
Part# 42611-04160
Dimensions: 16x7 +25
Weight 23lbs
or

go for 255/70/17 (37 lbs)
with 4Runner TRD Sema Pro - Matte Black
Part# PTR20-35110-BK
Dimensions: 17x7 +04
Weight: 25 lbs

Any recommendations?
Is anyone else running the Toyos? Or these sizes?
What do you guys think?

 

I just put 3rd gen OR wheels and Toyo 3’S on my 12 2.7 in stock size 245 75 16. I’m happy with them. Ride really nice good on wet and dry. Haven’t off roaded yet. Waiting on some snow to see how they will do.