Need new tires. Any experience with these?

2019 Double Cab 2wd Stock
Very occasional off-road
Mainly city driving.

I need to replace my stock tires. I am looking at these two tires.
Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain Plus
Bridgestone Dueler A/T Revo 3

Want something that will last. Performs well in dry and wet. Is quiet.
Off road performance is the least important thing but I want a tire that does not look wimpy either.

Any recommendations or experience between these two tires? Open to other suggestions as well.
Thanks

 

IMO stock size Mastercraft Stratus AP.

 

Bridgestone Dueler A/T Revo 3 gets my vote

 

I run a model of Bridgestone Dueler (not your model) on my little 5 lug and have found them to be quite satisfactory.

Costco.

 

I'm leaning towards the Bridgestone for sure. I had a pair of Revo 2's and liked them. The Pirellis have a better rating on tire rack but I'm not sure about Pirelli truck tires.

 

The original Pirelli's were not that great of a tire. But I had the newer AT Plus on my F150 and liked them. If off road driving isn't important just buy Michelin's.

 

I ran the Dueler AT/3 on a Lexus GX470 and they were decent - except in rain, where they tended to hydroplane. These were 255/75r17 Load Range C (32x10.50 roughly) on a +5k lb rig, running 34-36 psi. Idathunk the skinnier profile on a pig would be better in the wet, but that was not the case - and that would be my only hesitation against running them again.

 

Of the 2 mentioned, Revo gets my vote. If you are willing to consider another, try the Yokohama Geolander GO15.

 

Neither are amazing, but decent middle of the road.

Agree with Yoko G015, slightly aggressive but much better performance.

 

Yokohama Go15 has really impressed me over the last 10,000 miles in snow, ice, mud, sand, slop, asphalt, etc.