Toyota Tacoma Bumper Damage

I've done the "same" thing. (X2) Under $600 in parts. Easy fix. Take the money and run.
They make it this way to make it cheap to fix.

 

just get the right side part, you can get them already painted, easy to put on, many videos out there, try ebay or Amazon or google.....dont make a big deal of fixing it cause you might damage it again in a week

 

Get you one of these. I have no idea where or how I got that white mark on the left corner. Probably a parking lot. Hehe.

 

This, hit twice as well. $800 in damages each time. I went on eBay purchased corner bumper piece for $100 and used the rest to pay for sliders and suspension.

 

I backed into a low level retaining wall. Did the ebay color matched off brand parts. It came out just fine.