Tire recommendation

Got a 2018 MGM DCSB Limited. I do little to no off-roading. Mostly small town driving, some highway. The Michelins that came with my 18" rims are totally fine. But fine is not good enough. This is what I want (no lift):
- 17" TRD Gunmetal rims (4Runner?)
- More aggressive looking, but still comfortable road-driving tire. I assume the size will be 265/70/17 to be able to keep the mud flaps without the lift. Also prefer good handling during winter. Less worried about actual off-road or mud performance. From my TW research, the common contenders seem to be the Falken Wildpeak At3W, BFG KO2, Nitto Grappler, or Toyo AT2. Of these, which ones would fit my purposes the best? Any other ones I should look into?

Thanks in advance.

 

I installed on my no lift 2018 sport 255/75/17
Road one MT tires for me they were the best bang for buck. I also installed it on a 2019 TRD OFFROAD
285/75/16 I have about 20,000 miles on them no issues great in all conditions. Might be a little too aggressive for you since no offroading. But for an MT they are quiet and well priced here is a link.

$183 Road One Cavalry M/T Mud Tire RL1293 255 75 17 LT255/75R17, C Load Rated

https://www.amazon.com/Cavalry-RL1293-LT255-75R17-Rated/dp/B07M94GKML

 

Mickey Thompson Deegan 38 AT's. Comfortable and plenty capable when you need them. Got em at 4wheelparts for a good deal

 

I would highly recommend not getting M/Ts if snow is a concern. M/T tires typically have less siping which is needed in snow and rain.

People are also pretty down on the KO2s in the rain and snow. I personally think you should consider Goodyear Duratracs along with your others. Especially if you can get SL or C Load.

Mine have been spectacular in every thing you're concerned about, have excellent road manners, and after 5k miles still have 16/32nds of their tread which is what they started with. Easily a 50k to 60k mile tire.