Switch from 17's to 16's for lift/tire combo?

Here goes- ive got a 2005 double cab long bed 4wd . I have the stock 17 x 9 sport wheels that are ok. Im putting front billys on set at 1.75 and rear AAL. My question is should i switch to a 16" rim (16 x 8) with about a 4.5" backspace and run a 265/75? I was going to put on the black raceline renegades and the goodyear duratracs. ive seen this on many tacos and it looks really good. Or should i keep a 17 x 9 with a 4.5 backspace? pics and opinions would help

 

i think less wheel more tire looks better! i would go with the 16!

 

Thats what i was thinking too, dont want to run a huge lift

 

Did you get that tire/wheel combo on? that's what I was thinking of getting. (renegade 6/duratracs 265/75/16) post pics if you did